The Caribbean Coalition for the Decolonisation of the Law (CCDL) is a collaborative initiative focused on legal research and strategic advocacy regarding the worsening of rights protections post-independence in some Caribbean nations. Its partners include leading advocacy groups across the region, such as CARIFLAGS, ILGA-NAC, ECADE, United Belize Advocacy Movement, Colours Caribbean (Cayman Islands), and Out Bermuda. Strengthening the initiative’s legal expertise and international dimension, the LGBTQ+ Advocacy Clinic and the Advocates for Human Rights, both at Harvard Law School, the Oxford Pro Bono Publico at the Oxford University’s Law Faculty and lawyers from firms in Canada, the USA, and Argentina are pro bono supporting their work.
CCDL’s Mission and Advocacy Approach
CCDL aims to challenge the continued influence of colonial judicial authority and its link to the persistence of discriminatory laws, advocating for their alignment with international human rights standards. Its work supports greater visibility of these issues to inform policy debate regarding decolonisation and human rights, and, ultimately, to seek an international legal finding on incompatibility between retained colonial judicature and international law.
The Issue:
Worsening of Rights Protections Post-Independence in the Caribbean
In several Caribbean countries, e.g., Bahamas, Jamaica, Trinidad and Tobago, colonial laws became entrenched and even unchallengeable in court after independence, worsening rights protections. This issue was highlighted by the UN Independent Expert on Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity (UNIEXP) at the 78th UN General Assembly, calling for an investigation into international legal responsibilities.
Shared feature: Colonial Retention of Judicial Authority
Despite formal independence, these countries still follow constitutional frameworks established by the UK during decolonisation. A shared feature of their frameworks (along with St Vincent and the Grenadines, Antigua and Barbuda, Grenada, and St. Kitts and Nevis) is that the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council (JCPC) retains authority, so British judges remain responsible for the construction and enforcement of their laws and constitutions. UNIEXP called this ongoing judicial retention the last remnant of British colonialism holding effective imperial power.
The International Court of Justice (in the Chagos case) affirmed independence and self-determination as inalienable rights, meaning these countries’ consent cannot negate the right to judicial self-determination, especially with all branches of government being equal in their written constitutional systems.
Similar Impact on Fundamental Rights
The retention of judicial authority by the UK has hindered the progress of fundamental rights in the Caribbean. In Bahamas, Jamaica and Trinidad and Tobago, British judges’ rulings regarding savings clauses have contributed to breaches of the rule of law by shielding discriminatory colonial laws from judicial scrutiny. In brief, the JCPC eliminated checks and balances and enabled Caribbean governments to act with impunity when enforcing colonial-era laws, leading to violations of key international human rights in areas such as gender, death penalty, inhumane and degrading treatment, and criminalisation of LGBTQI+ individuals. These decisions have caused harm to individuals and communities, arguably Caribbean people may be materially worse off in constitutional terms after independence than under direct British rule, and, also, exposed Caribbean states to international liabilities.
